How to handle old mattresses the right way
Mattress disposal in Evansville: recycling, costs, and pickup options

Old mattresses are bulky, hard to haul, and often not accepted by regular trash pickup in Evansville, IN. With over 20 million mattresses disposed of annually in the US, finding the right disposal method is crucial for both environmental and budget considerations. Here's your comprehensive guide to mattress disposal options in the Tri-State area.
Professional Mattress Removal Services
Professional mattress removal is the most convenient option for Evansville residents. Services typically include pickup from any location in your home, loading, transportation, and proper disposal or recycling.
Average Costs in Evansville
- Single mattress removal: $89-119
- Mattress + box spring set: $114-149
- Multiple mattresses: 10-15% discount available
- Same-day service: Often available with no additional fee
- Upstairs/basement pickup: Usually included in base price
City of Evansville Bulk Waste Options
The City of Evansville offers bulk waste pickup twice per year for residents. However, this service has limitations:
- Limited to specific scheduled dates (typically spring and fall)
- Items must be placed curbside the night before collection
- Weather exposure can damage mattresses before pickup
- Not available for immediate disposal needs
Mattress Recycling in Southern Indiana
Mattress recycling is environmentally beneficial but has limited availability in the Evansville area. Here's what you need to know:
What Can Be Recycled
- Metal springs: 100% recyclable as scrap metal
- Wood frames: Can be processed into biomass or mulch
- Foam padding: Some types can be recycled into carpet padding
- Fabric covering: Limited recycling options, often downcycled
Local Recycling Challenges
While mattress recycling is ideal, the Tri-State area has limited facilities. Most professional removal services will separate materials when possible, but complete recycling isn't always available locally.
Donation Opportunities
Donating mattresses in good condition can benefit local families, but health regulations limit acceptance:
- Goodwill Evansville: Generally does not accept mattresses due to hygiene concerns
- Salvation Army: Rarely accepts mattresses, call ahead to confirm
- Local churches: Some may accept high-quality mattresses for specific needs
- Facebook Marketplace/Craigslist: Best option for mattresses in excellent condition
Why Choose Professional Removal
For most Evansville residents, professional mattress removal offers the best combination of convenience, speed, and environmental responsibility:
- Same-day availability: No waiting for bulk pickup schedules
- Indoor pickup: No need to move heavy mattresses yourself
- Weather-independent: Service available year-round
- Proper disposal: Licensed companies ensure legal, eco-friendly disposal
- Insurance coverage: Professional services carry liability insurance
Timing Your Mattress Disposal
Consider these factors when planning mattress removal in Evansville:
- Moving dates: Schedule removal for the day after your new mattress delivery
- Seasonal considerations: Spring and fall are popular times for mattress replacement
- Holiday schedules: Some services have limited availability during major holidays
- Same-day needs: Call early in the day for best same-day availability
Bottom Line: Professional mattress removal in Evansville typically costs $89-149 and offers the most convenient, reliable solution for disposing of old mattresses while ensuring proper environmental handling.